Previous: The Brain Scoop
Next: The Two-Faced Calf, Part I



View count:88,242
Last sync:2024-06-05 14:30


Citation formatting is not guaranteed to be accurate.
MLA Full: "Starstuff and Nanodiamonds." YouTube, uploaded by thebrainscoop, 12 March 2014,
MLA Inline: (thebrainscoop, 2014)
APA Full: thebrainscoop. (2014, March 12). Starstuff and Nanodiamonds [Video]. YouTube.
APA Inline: (thebrainscoop, 2014)
Chicago Full: thebrainscoop, "Starstuff and Nanodiamonds.", March 12, 2014, YouTube, 06:40,
Wherein I meet our collective origins.

Huge thanks to Dr. Philipp Heck for helping to create this episode. His research is totally out of this world.


NEW! Subreddit:


The Brain Scoop is written and hosted by:
Emily Graslie

Created By:
Hank Green

Directed, Edited, Animated, and Scored by:
Michael Aranda

Production Assistant:
Katie Kirby

Filmed on Location and Supported by:
The Field Museum in Chicago, IL

Thanks to Lindsey Thomas for transcribing and Tony Chu, Barbara Velázquez, John-Alan Pascoe, Seth Bergenholtz, and Katerina Idrik for translating this episode! You guys are true shooting stars.
Emily: I'm here with Philipp Heck who is the Robert A. Pritzker associate curator of meteach- meteori- oh shoot

Philipp Heck: The Robert A. Pritzker associate curator for meteoritics and polar studies

Emily: There

Philipp: I practice too sometimes

Emily: Yeah. *laughs* Today we're going to talk about the age of the solar system

Philipp: This large, white aluminum ridge inclusions that you can see here: these are the oldest minerals that formed in the solar system and they can be dated and it's basically the start of the solar system. You call it T0, Time Zero. It's 4.567 billion years. It's an easy number to remember: 4.567 billion.

Emily: We know how old the solar system is because of this specific specimen.

Philipp: Exactly. Exactly. This defines T0. When I give the public talks I usually, um, give people a slice in a plastic and I say "You can hold the oldest  of material in the solar system and even,  you don't see it, it is the oldest material available to anyone on this planet is in there." There's nothing older that you can touch.

Emily: Wow

Philipp: Pre-solar grains, they're older than the sun, older than the meteorite itself. Some of them might be as old as 5 and a half billion years.

Emily: Wow. And how do you know that?

Philipp: So these pre-solar grains, it can be analyzed chemically. Their isotopic composition is highly anomalous, very different from anything in the solar system. Their composition can not be explained by any process that can occur in the solar system. The fact that they are embedded in that rock tells us they could not have been incorporated later. They must have been part of the mixture from which the rock formed. An since the rock formed 4.6 billion years ago, they must be older.

Emily: Older than 4.6 billion years.

Philipp: Yeah. And some minerals even can be dated. So far we have only dated approximately 30 grains. Most of them are about 200 million years older than the sun. And a few of them are about a billion years older than the sun which makes them about 5 or 6 billion years old. We think the solar system formed, basically, from a cloud of gas and dust. And this cloud of gas and dust formed from different sources from different stars. Some of these stars were, indeed, stellar explosions: super novae. They exploded and during these explosions new elements formed. After the matter cooled down some of this matter condensed as gas. There were other stars, many other stars, which were like the sun but they were already at the end of their life. They expanded, became red giants, and expelled the matter into space. And from all these mixtures of stellar ejecta, this pre-solar cloud formed. Within this pre-solar molecular cloud, the proto-solar disc formed. It is basically a rotating disc of gas and dust. The proto-sun formed and later, the sun. Planetary building blocks formed. Most of the matter was altered, heated. The pre-solar signature is not visible anymore but some of this pre-solar matter survived without having been altered. That's what's trapped in here. It's only a tiny fraction, the most abundant type of pre-solar materials are diamonds, nanodiamonds. These diamonds are tiny: they are only 2 manometers across. Maybe consist of one thousand to two thousand carbon atoms. We can extract them from meteorites. We basically dissolve everything else, just are left with the acid residue of diamonds and in this little vial I have billions of diamonds. You normally wouldn't see them because they are so small they wouldn't scatter light but they clump together. So you can see that white residue?

Emily: Yeah

Philipp: These are all diamonds. It's literally stardust.

Emily: It's...awfully ethereal-looking. It kind of, like, floats around in this nebulous nest and-

Philipp: These diamonds: they were discovered in Chicago in 1987 at The University of Chicago with a Field Museum meteorite.

Emily: Really? That's..That's- It's overwhelming. It's a...It's a- How did you- How did you get into this?

Philipp: Yeah, so when I heard about this first I was extremely fascinated and, and uh I heard about it when I was student of earth science in Switzerland and did an undergraduate project in a- in a cosmochemistry lab there. I thought "oh, this is so fascinating, would it be possible to do a PhD there?"

Emily: Yeah.

Philipp: Just because I was completely hooked. I was always interested in astronomy and, uh, volunteered at the local observatory there and said "Oh, if I could do that for a living, that would be fantastic." And yeah, actually the opportunity came up and I was able to work on the stardust during- for my PhD.

Emily: Really?

Philipp: And, uh, everything, yeah, so I'm very fortunate to be- to work on such a very, I would say, on the oldest matter that is available anywhere on this planet. It's, eh, it keeps us very motivated and

Emily: *laughs*

Philipp: And, eh, it's really great.

Emily: Yeah.

Philipp: We do "every question that you answer, you open ten more questions that can be studied"  but then you have to make a wise decision: which questions are actually worth pursuing to answer?

Emily: Yeah.

Philipp: Worth the time and money. And one of these is actually origin of those nanodiamonds because nanodiamonds are basically pure carbon. And they survived the formation and evolution of our solar system. And almost nothing else did survive. Almost everything has been altered. So the carbon in our body and our skin: you don't see a pre-solar signature anymore.

Emily: Yeah.

Philipp: Although it might have the same origin as these diamonds.

Emily: So, the carbon that makes up those diamonds is the same carbon that makes up you- like, the carbon within me and you.

Philipp: Exactly.

Emily: And all of life on earth.

Philip: Exactly.

Emily: So this is, like, our great times infinity great great ancestor, essentially.

Philipp: Yeah. So I think we have a common origin.

Emily: Yeah.

Philip: With diamonds and life on earth. And this is a proxy of- it's basically the tiny fraction that survived all these billions of years since the earth- since the planets and the earth formed. And by studying those diamonds, they open up basically- they are like a time capsule. By studying them we can learn about past, about a time before the solar system.

Michael: So if you were to take those diamonds down to a pawn shop, how much is one of them worth?

Emily: *laughs* You would not even know.

Philipp: I don't know but I always tell- they probably wouldn't make nice engagement rings because they're so small

Michael and Emily: Yeah.

Philip: But there are millions.