vlogbrothers
You Don't Want a Gas Stovetop
YouTube: | https://youtube.com/watch?v=Bcqah8U_uKA |
Previous: | My Most Valuable Books |
Next: | On the Death of My Hero |
Categories
Statistics
View count: | 283,041 |
Likes: | 25,302 |
Comments: | 4,835 |
Duration: | 03:51 |
Uploaded: | 2022-02-18 |
Last sync: | 2024-12-03 22:15 |
Citation
Citation formatting is not guaranteed to be accurate. | |
MLA Full: | "You Don't Want a Gas Stovetop." YouTube, uploaded by vlogbrothers, 18 February 2022, www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bcqah8U_uKA. |
MLA Inline: | (vlogbrothers, 2022) |
APA Full: | vlogbrothers. (2022, February 18). You Don't Want a Gas Stovetop [Video]. YouTube. https://youtube.com/watch?v=Bcqah8U_uKA |
APA Inline: | (vlogbrothers, 2022) |
Chicago Full: |
vlogbrothers, "You Don't Want a Gas Stovetop.", February 18, 2022, YouTube, 03:51, https://youtube.com/watch?v=Bcqah8U_uKA. |
OK, so I was both passionately disorganized and time-limited so here's a little more information:
Problems with Gas Stoves
They release fairly dangerous chemicals into your home, including nitrogen dioxide which is quite bad for you. A recent meta-analysis of dozens of studies showed that kids who live in a house with gas cooktops have a 41% higher chance of experiencing asthma.
They introduce a significant danger of fire and explosion, especially in homes with children or people with memory problems.
They are harder to clean than induction cooktops.
They get much hotter than induction cooktops.
They heat up far more slowly and make cooking take more time.
VERY IMPORTANTLY household methane use is actually a really big contributor to climate change and we are going to have to, over the next 30 years, stop doing it. People don't care about their hot water heater as long as it's reasonably priced and works well, but people have emotional connections to their gas ranges, and that could be a really silly reason to make climate change significantly worse.
The only advantages of gas cooktops over induction:
They can (though this isn't always the case) have a little more control over heat than induction (though induction cooktops /can/ have that control, they just sometimes don't).
Induction cooktops don't work with copper, aluminum, or glass cookware.
At the moment, the cheapest gas ranges are cheaper than the cheapest induction cooktops (though government incentives SHOULD CHANGE THIS PLEASE.)
THINGS I LEFT OUT OF THIS VIDEO
There are places (I live in one of them) where we will likely need to deliver gas (possibly hydrogen, but who knows) to people's houses because it sometimes gets below -20 degrees F and it's hard to make heat pumps work well at that temperature. But in the next 20 years, it's completely possible that that problem will be solved.
Regardless, 90% of people in the US live in places where it never gets that cold. That percentage is increasing as people move to warmer places and the colder places get warmer.
----
Subscribe to our newsletter! https://nerdfighteria.com/nerdfighteria-newsletter
And join the community at http://nerdfighteria.com
Help transcribe videos - http://nerdfighteria.info
Learn more about our project to help Partners in Health radically reduce maternal mortality in Sierra Leone: https://www.pih.org/hankandjohn
If you're able to donate $2,000 or more to this effort, please join our matching fund: https://pih.org/hankandjohnmatch
John's twitter - http://twitter.com/johngreen
Hank's twitter - http://twitter.com/hankgreen
Hank's tumblr - http://edwardspoonhands.tumblr.com
Book club: http://www.lifeslibrarybookclub.com/
Problems with Gas Stoves
They release fairly dangerous chemicals into your home, including nitrogen dioxide which is quite bad for you. A recent meta-analysis of dozens of studies showed that kids who live in a house with gas cooktops have a 41% higher chance of experiencing asthma.
They introduce a significant danger of fire and explosion, especially in homes with children or people with memory problems.
They are harder to clean than induction cooktops.
They get much hotter than induction cooktops.
They heat up far more slowly and make cooking take more time.
VERY IMPORTANTLY household methane use is actually a really big contributor to climate change and we are going to have to, over the next 30 years, stop doing it. People don't care about their hot water heater as long as it's reasonably priced and works well, but people have emotional connections to their gas ranges, and that could be a really silly reason to make climate change significantly worse.
The only advantages of gas cooktops over induction:
They can (though this isn't always the case) have a little more control over heat than induction (though induction cooktops /can/ have that control, they just sometimes don't).
Induction cooktops don't work with copper, aluminum, or glass cookware.
At the moment, the cheapest gas ranges are cheaper than the cheapest induction cooktops (though government incentives SHOULD CHANGE THIS PLEASE.)
THINGS I LEFT OUT OF THIS VIDEO
There are places (I live in one of them) where we will likely need to deliver gas (possibly hydrogen, but who knows) to people's houses because it sometimes gets below -20 degrees F and it's hard to make heat pumps work well at that temperature. But in the next 20 years, it's completely possible that that problem will be solved.
Regardless, 90% of people in the US live in places where it never gets that cold. That percentage is increasing as people move to warmer places and the colder places get warmer.
----
Subscribe to our newsletter! https://nerdfighteria.com/nerdfighteria-newsletter
And join the community at http://nerdfighteria.com
Help transcribe videos - http://nerdfighteria.info
Learn more about our project to help Partners in Health radically reduce maternal mortality in Sierra Leone: https://www.pih.org/hankandjohn
If you're able to donate $2,000 or more to this effort, please join our matching fund: https://pih.org/hankandjohnmatch
John's twitter - http://twitter.com/johngreen
Hank's twitter - http://twitter.com/hankgreen
Hank's tumblr - http://edwardspoonhands.tumblr.com
Book club: http://www.lifeslibrarybookclub.com/
Good Morning, John. I've had a half a cup of coffee and I'm going to do something I almost never do. I'm gonna make an unscripted video about a thing that I care, very passionately, about.
You, watching this video to not want a gas stove. Why? Because they suck. Here's the thing that you are right about, the curly-cue heating element stoves, they are the worst. They're hard to clean, they're extremely hard to control. Like you cannot turn them on and off quickly. They take forever to heat up. They take forever to cool down. But what happened is the stovetop and natural gas industry made it so that what takes the place of that in your brain is a natural gas stove. That has like the little blue flames that are so beautiful, that like Gordon Ramsey uses.
But what you're doing, when you have a natural gas stove, is burning stuff in your home. Which results in, get this, decreased indoor air quality. And you can get around this by like having your fume hood going full blast, and certainly never have a natural gas stove that doesn't have a hood. Or! Get this! You can have an induction stovetop that has more power and is easier to control than natural gas.
Chances are, there are three pipes connected to your house. There's the one that brings you water, that one's important. The one that takes the water away, we also want that. And the one that brings you methane! What century is this?! It would be like having the gas station bring the gasoline directly to your car. Like, this is a bad idea. Now I know what you're thinking, Hank there is no way that cooking my HelloFresh is significantly adding to climate change. And you're right, but here's the thing, household natural gas use is a big contributor to climate change. Just not mostly the stovetop. However, when natural gas companies ask people how they feel about switching their furnace from gas to electric, or their water heater from gas to electric, they're like, 'I don't care. Whichever. Whichever's better. I don't know.' Because you currently have a really efficient way to get power into your home that isn't a pipe full of methane. It's a power line. And there are great electric water heaters. And there are great electric furnaces and heat pumps. But people say I want my natural gas stove. But that's a tiny percentage of the methane that is actually being sold by the gas companies. Almost all of that is being used by furnaces and water heaters. But as long as people are like, 'I want to keep my gas stove. It's harder to clean, it makes the air inside my house dirty, but House Hunters says that it's a top-tier product.'
People will keep having the natural gas companies build and replace this extremely expensive infrastructure to pipe gas into our homes. And gas companies are freaking out about this. And they're doing all these campaigns about how great gas ranges are, even though they are objectively worse. Because if they can keep that toehold, they can make it make sense to keep giving you gas for the other things that electric could easily replace. But look, electric could also easily replace your stove. Because induction stovetops are better than gas. And so, one of the most important things you can do as a person who is concerned about climate change is take the little thing out of your brain that says that gas stoves are the best kind of stove. And look at it and be like 'You're a freaking idiot.'
And you throw it on top of your induction stovetop and nothing happens. Because that's not how it works. It induces the heat in the pan. The stovetop itself doesn't get hot, because they're amazing. So you have to put it into a pan, put that on the stovetop, and fry it up. And have it with butter.
This is why I script! That right there is why I script! So that doesn't happen! It's not important that you replace your gas stove right now. In fact, it's probably best that you don't. It's important that you don't think it's better than an induction, because it's not. Because at some point in the future, someone is going to knock on your door and say, 'This area is about to have its natural gas pipes replaced, and we have to decide whether or not to replace them with infrastructure that will last 60-80 years.' And if a bunch of people in your neighborhood say, 'Well, I would but I really like my gas stovetop, it's not going to happen.' And we're going to keep burning methane in people's houses for 80 years! I would be sympathetic if gas were better. But it's not!
John, I'll see you on Tuesday.
You, watching this video to not want a gas stove. Why? Because they suck. Here's the thing that you are right about, the curly-cue heating element stoves, they are the worst. They're hard to clean, they're extremely hard to control. Like you cannot turn them on and off quickly. They take forever to heat up. They take forever to cool down. But what happened is the stovetop and natural gas industry made it so that what takes the place of that in your brain is a natural gas stove. That has like the little blue flames that are so beautiful, that like Gordon Ramsey uses.
But what you're doing, when you have a natural gas stove, is burning stuff in your home. Which results in, get this, decreased indoor air quality. And you can get around this by like having your fume hood going full blast, and certainly never have a natural gas stove that doesn't have a hood. Or! Get this! You can have an induction stovetop that has more power and is easier to control than natural gas.
Chances are, there are three pipes connected to your house. There's the one that brings you water, that one's important. The one that takes the water away, we also want that. And the one that brings you methane! What century is this?! It would be like having the gas station bring the gasoline directly to your car. Like, this is a bad idea. Now I know what you're thinking, Hank there is no way that cooking my HelloFresh is significantly adding to climate change. And you're right, but here's the thing, household natural gas use is a big contributor to climate change. Just not mostly the stovetop. However, when natural gas companies ask people how they feel about switching their furnace from gas to electric, or their water heater from gas to electric, they're like, 'I don't care. Whichever. Whichever's better. I don't know.' Because you currently have a really efficient way to get power into your home that isn't a pipe full of methane. It's a power line. And there are great electric water heaters. And there are great electric furnaces and heat pumps. But people say I want my natural gas stove. But that's a tiny percentage of the methane that is actually being sold by the gas companies. Almost all of that is being used by furnaces and water heaters. But as long as people are like, 'I want to keep my gas stove. It's harder to clean, it makes the air inside my house dirty, but House Hunters says that it's a top-tier product.'
People will keep having the natural gas companies build and replace this extremely expensive infrastructure to pipe gas into our homes. And gas companies are freaking out about this. And they're doing all these campaigns about how great gas ranges are, even though they are objectively worse. Because if they can keep that toehold, they can make it make sense to keep giving you gas for the other things that electric could easily replace. But look, electric could also easily replace your stove. Because induction stovetops are better than gas. And so, one of the most important things you can do as a person who is concerned about climate change is take the little thing out of your brain that says that gas stoves are the best kind of stove. And look at it and be like 'You're a freaking idiot.'
And you throw it on top of your induction stovetop and nothing happens. Because that's not how it works. It induces the heat in the pan. The stovetop itself doesn't get hot, because they're amazing. So you have to put it into a pan, put that on the stovetop, and fry it up. And have it with butter.
This is why I script! That right there is why I script! So that doesn't happen! It's not important that you replace your gas stove right now. In fact, it's probably best that you don't. It's important that you don't think it's better than an induction, because it's not. Because at some point in the future, someone is going to knock on your door and say, 'This area is about to have its natural gas pipes replaced, and we have to decide whether or not to replace them with infrastructure that will last 60-80 years.' And if a bunch of people in your neighborhood say, 'Well, I would but I really like my gas stovetop, it's not going to happen.' And we're going to keep burning methane in people's houses for 80 years! I would be sympathetic if gas were better. But it's not!
John, I'll see you on Tuesday.