YouTube: https://youtube.com/watch?v=ZDlcqG7Kuho
Previous: Your Allergies Might Prevent Cancer
Next: (None)

Categories

Statistics

View count:810
Likes:92
Comments:9
Duration:15:01
Uploaded:2026-11-19
Last sync:2026-11-19 18:15

Citation

Citation formatting is not guaranteed to be accurate.
MLA Full: "Those Ape Sign Language Studies May Have Been Bogus." YouTube, uploaded by SciShow, 19 November 2026, www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZDlcqG7Kuho.
MLA Inline: (SciShow, 2026)
APA Full: SciShow. (2026, November 19). Those Ape Sign Language Studies May Have Been Bogus [Video]. YouTube. https://youtube.com/watch?v=ZDlcqG7Kuho
APA Inline: (SciShow, 2026)
Chicago Full: SciShow, "Those Ape Sign Language Studies May Have Been Bogus.", November 19, 2026, YouTube, 15:01,
https://youtube.com/watch?v=ZDlcqG7Kuho.
Visit https://brilliant.org/scishow/ to get started with Brilliant’s tutor for free and get 20% off your annual premium subscription.

You may have heard of Koko, the famous gorilla who could use sign language. She's not the only ape that humans have tried to teach language, with.... varying results. So, can apes really talk? Let's see what the science says.

Hosted by: Reid Reimers (he/him)
----------
Support us for $8/month on Patreon and keep SciShow going!
https://www.patreon.com/scishow
Or support us directly: https://complexly.com/support
Join our SciShow email list to get the latest news and highlights:
https://mailchi.mp/scishow/email
----------
Huge thanks go to the following Patreon supporters for helping us keep SciShow free for everyone forever: ., Adam Brainard, Alex Hackman, Bethany Matthews, Blood Doctor Kelly, Cye Stoner, Anita, Anne Herrington, Friso, Jeremy Mattern, Garrett Galloway, Chris Curry, Chris Mackey, Chris Peters, David Johnston, Eric Jensen, J.V. Rosenbalm, Jaap Westera, Jacob Puthoff, Jason A Saslow, Jon Coffman, Joseph Ruf, Jp Lynch, Kevin Bealer, Kevin Knupp, Lyndsay Brown, Matt Curls, Piya Shedden, Shaji John, Steve Gums, Timos Gies, Toyas Dhake, yeyette
----------
Looking for SciShow elsewhere on the internet?
SciShow Tangents Podcast: https://scishow-tangents.simplecast.com/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@scishow
Instagram: http://instagram.com/thescishow
Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/scishow
Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/scishow.bsky.social

#SciShow #science #education #learning #complexly
----------
Sources: https://docs.google.com/document/d/e/2PACX-1vRAAugwMSLkCr3CPI1bG0vKfN1acFTtukvIe5ZiX-MlJ7RqV_r8rNDFwugmqMt22a4QLgHhnIKkl7Bl/pub
In October of 1978, the National Geographic cover featured a gorilla taking  her own photo in a mirror.

That gorilla was Koko, probably  the most famous one of all time. Over the course of her life,  she appeared in magazines, was the subject of multiple books, and even rubbed elbows with celebrities like Robin Williams and Betty White.

And her claim to fame? Well, she could talk. She had been trained to use sign language, and could even form combinations  of words to arrive at new meanings.

Or at least, that’s what the  researchers who worked with her claimed. And the thing is, when it comes to  signing simians, she’s not alone. Several other researchers have tried to teach chimps to use language too.

But did the apes actually  know what they were saying? Let’s discuss. [♪INTRO] Before we get to the talking chimps and gorillas, let’s address the other talking apes. Us!

In the mid-20th century,  anthropologists and linguists wanted to know why humans have  the capacity to use language, and whether any other animals  can learn how to gab too. Obviously animals have their  own ways to communicate, but bird chirps and frog croaks lack many of the major elements that make  something a real language. All language is communication, but  not all communication is language.

Human language can do things  like talk about abstract ideas, or things that are not here and  now, create endless new phrases to talk about any topic we could  possibly want to talk about, and even talk about itself,  like we’re doing right now. While some other forms of  communication may have some of these features, no other animal  communication can do it all. But even though researchers know what language is, it’s been a lot harder to reach  a consensus on how we got it.

In general, there are two schools of thought. One is that the tools we need to use language are hard-wired in humans as pre-loaded software, and the other is that language  arises by making sounds or gestures that end up gaining  meaning over generations. Either way, when a baby is exposed  to language from their parents and community, they absorb the  rules of the game and get chatty.

If the software is baked in, that  means that, as far as we can tell, humans are the only living animals that have it. But if it’s not, well, what’s stopping us from teaching other animals to use language like we do? The main proponent of the  idea that language is innately and exclusively human is a guy named Noam Chomsky.

He’s said that animals are  incapable of using language because of their cognitive  abilities, not their anatomy. Although, he's been in the news for... something else lately. But other researchers wanted  to disprove the idea that language is a human-only thing, and they did so by trying to teach apes to use language, too.

The earliest experiments involved  trying to teach chimps to speak, but they don’t have the mouth and throat anatomy for most sounds we make, so that didn’t go well. But talking isn’t the only way to use language, and this is why researchers  turned to sign languages. Signed languages have formed all over the world in all kinds of cultures  and contexts, and they have all the features that make a language, a language.

Plus, chimps are VERY good at hand gestures, so it seems like a great match. And so, the early attempts to teach chimps  American Sign Language began. The first of these sign language studies started with Alan and Beatrice Gardner, who acquired a baby chimp in  1966 and called her Washoe.

They raised her as if she were their human child, in their own backyard, to see if Washoe could learn language like human babies do. They would communicate with  Washoe both out loud and in ASL, and Washoe would imitate some of their signs. They would repeat her signs  back to her to reinforce them, thinking that imitation was a  key to language acquisition.

But here’s the thing. Baby  chimps may look cute and cuddly, but adult chimps are, to put it  mildly, absolutely terrifying. So when Washoe got bigger  and too dangerous to keep in their home, the Gardners sent  her to a facility in Oklahoma.

They sent her with one of their  grad students, Roger Fouts, who, along with his wife Deborah, ran  the research program with Washoe. And over the decades, they added several other chimps to the training program. Between the Gardners and the  Fouts’ training programs, Washoe learned and consistently  used at least 250 signs, and she even taught a younger  chimp named Loulis how to sign too.

She would mold his hands  into the shapes of the signs, just like the Gardners had done  for her when she was a baby. Which sounds like a pretty promising  first step towards language! While Washoe was learning her  words, another researcher named Herbert S.

Terrace started his  own chimp-signing program too. When it came to Noam Chomsky  and his innate language ideas, Terrace was a big hater. So he decided to name the chimp  in his studies Nim Chimpsky.

Oof. The shade! Unlike Washoe, Nim’s training took place in a true laboratory environment and  involved many researchers trying to teach Nim how to  sign, all recorded on video.

His results were pretty shocking,  and we’ll get to why in a bit. But while both of these chimps  got some limelight in their day, the most famous talking ape of all time was Koko. Before we can talk about Koko, all research needs funding, even ours.

So here’s a quick ad. Thanks for watching SciShow  and staying curious with us! We hope that after watching a SciShow video, you truly understand a  little more about the world. …Just like after you try Brilliant: an online math tutor designed to help students, from fifth grade through  college, truly understand math.

Brilliant knows that any kid can be a math kid. It teaches math through interactive, visual lessons that keep students engaged. It also keeps track of what  each student has mastered and where they still need  help, then makes practice just for them to ensure that every concept sticks.

Click the link below or scan the  QR code to try Brilliant for free. You can upgrade to Premium to unlock all courses. And right now, SciShow viewers can save 20% off an annual subscription at brilliant.org/scishow.

In 1971, a gorilla was born  at the San Francisco zoo. She was named Hanabi-Ko, meaning  “Fireworks Child” in Japanese, but her nickname was Koko. As an infant, Koko was very  sick and had to be separated from other gorillas for a few months, meaning that she was hand-raised by humans really young.

One of those humans was a PhD  student named Francine Patterson. After working with Koko as a baby,  Patterson started Project Koko, a long-term study where  researchers would communicate with Koko in both ASL and spoken  English, starting at about 5 hours a day, then expanding to 8 and 12 hours. By the age of 4, Koko was reported to use over 150 different signs every day.

Overall, she had a vocabulary  of more than 1,000 signs and the ability to understand  2,000 words of spoken English. Patterson also reported that Koko could use facial gestures to express questions, which is a requirement in ASL grammar, but isn’t something that you  see apes doing in the wild. Since so many apes learned how to sign, it seems pretty obvious that apes  can learn to use language, right?

Well, here’s where it gets complicated. See, none of these researchers published a full record of their data, only bits and pieces. They edited out incoherent utterances, or trimmed them down to  sound like a regular phrase, which didn’t reflect what the  animals had actually signed.

The editing could make an ape’s  signs sound coherent while in reality they’d just made a random  string of signs placed together. Once, when Washoe signed “you me you out”, it was recorded in the data sheets as “you me,” or when she signed “Susan bite  there,” it was recorded as “there.” Cutting out the other signs  and gestures and not publishing full transcripts of sessions  makes it impossible to know if a meaningful sign combination was  intentional or just a lucky guess. For instance, there’s a famous  anecdote that Washoe once combined the signs for water  and bird to refer to a duck, which sounds like she was combining  words to create a new meaning, which is a hallmark of language skills.

But hypothetically, if Washoe was  also known to sign “water hat” and “water cookie” and “go water”  and “sad water” all the time, that would make it seem like she’s not combining signs to arrive at new meaning, and might just mean she likes  to sign the word water a lot. And we have no way to know if  that was happening, because…. Nobody can see the transcripts!

Plus, familiar trainers would assign meanings to the signs that we can’t know  if the ape actually intended. For instance, another chimp from  the Fouts’s program named Tatu, uses the sign for “black”  frequently, which looks like this. Her trainers say that she uses that sign to mean something is cool or interesting.

But like… how do you know that’s what Tatu means? There are signs for cool and interesting, so it doesn’t really make sense  that Tatu knows the real meaning of that sign and is using it  as her own personal slang. For all we know, Tatu could  have an itchy forehead.

Not only that, but gestures  that apes naturally do, with no human involvement, were interpreted as signs with no distinction  from learned gestures. Patterson herself even wrote  that the signs for words like “up” and “go” look similar to hand  gestures that gorillas do in the wild, which means there’s an  argument to be made that those movements are just gorilla things,  not an attempt at using signs. It’s also worth mentioning that  in the field of anthropology, Patterson is, to put it mildly, controversial.

And I won’t say more, because  I don’t want us to get sued. Suffice to say, people have criticized a lot more about Koko’s training program  than just her sign language. The ways researchers designed their  experiments were also not great.

For example, the Gardeners  decided that for a sign to be considered a part of Washoe’s  vocabulary, she had to sign it every day, spontaneously and appropriately  for a certain number of days. So they essentially drilled certain signs with her constantly so she  could check all the boxes. And that doesn’t exactly sound like how human babies learn language, does it?

It’s more like dog training. The researchers just trained their  apes using treats and motivation. The apes learned that doing certain movements got them snacks or toys or apparently, tickles.

Did you know that chimps like  being tickled? I sure didn’t. So if a chimp gets a tickle every time they move their hands a certain way, well, they’re gonna want to do that more often.

There’s no way to know if the ape knows that the sign is connected to the  concept you are imparting. It’s like, if you teach a dog the command sit, they learn that when you  make that particular sound, their butt should hit the floor. But that doesn’t mean they know  what the word sit actually means.

One paper even said that Washoe’s signing was dependent upon her teachers. She almost exclusively signed as  a reaction to a teacher’s input, not offering her own signs to start  the conversation, so to speak. And Nim wasn’t any better.

He would mostly try to grab the things he wanted, without using signs at all. His teachers would then prompt him with questions like “what color crayon?”, ”more  book?”, or, simply, “sign!” He’d only make the signs when it became clear that he wouldn’t get what  he wanted without doing it. However, there are some chimps who seem to sign without any prompting.

Researchers from The Fauna Foundation, where Tatu and Loulis are now  kept, say that Tatu and Loulis will sign to each other,  researchers, other chimps, and even to themselves when  no other chimps are around. Which is all pretty interesting,  but again, just making the sign doesn’t tell us that  they know what the sign means. But don’t take our word for  it.

In the end, the loudest voice arguing that Nim  couldn’t use real language was… Herbert Terrace. He became so convinced that Nim wasn’t using language that he  changed his tune completely, and supported the innate-language  idea put forth by Chomsky. He presented his findings at a  major New York Academy of Sciences conference devoted to the Clever Hans problem: the possibility that studies  showing apparent animal intelligence were the result  of inadvertent human cueing.

And when Terrace showed what  he’d found with Nim Chimpsky, it turned the tide against  ape-language studies almost overnight. But the biggest fundamental flaw in all of these studies is that they’re  happening in captivity. Training an animal to do a behavior that doesn’t happen in the wild can’t tell you all that much about how they behave in their environment.

Humans didn’t evolve language in a lab setting, so if we want to know more  about the origins of language, it doesn’t make sense to  just look at apes in a lab.. Today, it’s considered unethical  and bad scientific practice to try hand-raising chimps  and studying them this way. And in 2015, the U.

S.  National Institutes of Health announced that they would  no longer support research on chimpanzees that were captured from the wild. As of February 2026, the only signing  chimps alive are Loulis and Tatu, who are enjoying a casual retirement  at a sanctuary in Montreal. Thanks to better technology  and new research methods, scientists can study ape communication by observing them in their natural environments, which makes a lot more  sense, if you think about it.

Some of this work shows  that both chimps and bonobos have the capacity for something  called compositionality, which is the ability to combine  small meaningful elements into larger meaningful structures, and  is another key feature of language. Other work also shows that orangutans  may be capable of recursion, another major language building block. All that to say, apes are doing just  fine on the communication front, no ASL or English or any other  human language necessary.

At the end of the day, none  of these signing experiments gave us concrete evidence  that our ape cousins are able to truly use human language in the same way we do. Although we know that some animals have some capacity to use some features of  language, as far as we can tell, no apes have full, true language use. Or if they do, they haven’t told us about it yet. [♪OUTRO]