YouTube: https://youtube.com/watch?v=JbTAVnyHB88
Previous: The Tiny Scorpions* In Your House
Next: We’ve Been Looking For This Plant For 2000 Years

Categories

Statistics

View count:197,550
Likes:9,898
Comments:594
Duration:14:28
Uploaded:2025-10-13
Last sync:2026-10-30 11:15
Martha died on September 1st, 1914. She was 29. Martha wasn’t your average Hollywood starlet – she was something even more rare: an endling, the last member of her species. Just a few hundred years earlier, passenger pigeons flocks were so large that they could literally darken the sky for hours. So how did we get from those numbers to extinction? And are they really gone for good?

Endlings portrait illustrations are by Zoe Keller. You can find out more about her and her work here: https://www.zoekeller.com/

Find out more about the National Geographic Photo Ark here: https://www.joelsartore.com/
https://www.youtube.com/@PhotoArk

Subscribe to the pin club here: https://complexly.store/products/bizarre-beasts-pin-subscription
You can cancel any time by emailing hello@dftba.com

Follow us on socials:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bizarrebeastsshow/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/BizarreBeastsShow/
Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/bizarrebeastsshow.bsky.social
#BizarreBeasts #Endlings #extinction #passengerpigeon
-----
Sources:
https://www.biodiversitylibrary.org/item/103784#page/348/mode/1up
https://www.si.edu/object/martha-passenger-pigeon%3Asiris_sic_11640#:~:text=Mounted%20in%20a%20display%20case,in%20the%20conservation%20of%20wildlife
https://www.si.edu/spotlight/passenger-pigeon
https://www.audubon.org/magazine/why-passenger-pigeon-went-extinct
https://www.allianceforthebay.org/2024/05/an-empty-sky-the-plight-of-the-passenger-pigeon/
https://digitalcommons.usf.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2044&context=american_birds
https://www.sfu.ca/geog315-new/readings/Ellsworth%282003%29.pdf
https://www.bbg.org/article/the_mysteries_of_masting_in_trees
https://naturemuseum.org/cas/project-passenger-pigeon
https://archive.org/details/passengerpigeoni0000scho/page/28/mode/2up?q=1910
https://web.archive.org/web/20160121214525/http://www.mnh.si.edu/onehundredyears/featured_objects/martha2.html
https://www.si.edu/es/exhibitions/objects-wonder:event-exhib-5999
https://birdsoftheworld.org/bow/species/paspig/cur/conservation
https://www.britannica.com/science/de-extinction
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6265789/#sec2-genes-09-00548
https://portals.iucn.org/library/sites/library/files/documents/Rep-2016-009.pdf
https://besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/1365-2435.12705
https://rewildingeurope.com/rewilding-in-action/wildlife-comeback/tauros/
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0093691X08007784
https://reviverestore.org/projects/about-the-passenger-pigeon/
https://reviverestore.org/projects/the-great-passenger-pigeon-comeback/progress-to-date/
https://archive.org/details/jstor-4071160/page/n9/mode/2up
https://esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1890/1540-9295-12.6.315
https://mnland.org/2024/09/10/extinction-passenger-pigeon/#:~:text=The%20speed%20at%20which%20the,impact%20while%20they%20were%20here
https://library.si.edu/event/lecture-and-book-signing-joel-greenberg
------
Images:
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1g0JEjz77GSwkrpeYbnRYhG1xrl4n45Tmea7Sw0q0u0M/edit?tab=t.0
“In the autumn of 1813, I  left my house at Henderson,   on the banks of the Ohio, on my way to Louisville.

In passing over the Barrens a  few miles beyond Hardensburgh,   I observed the pigeons flying from north-east to  south-west, in greater numbers than I thought I   had ever seen them before, and feeling an  inclination to count the flocks that might   pass within the reach of my eye in one hour,  I dismounted, seated myself on an eminence,   and began to mark with my pencil, making  a dot for every flock that passed. In a short time finding the task which I had  undertaken impracticable, as the birds poured   in in countless multitudes, I rose, and counting  the dots then put down, found that 163 had been   made in twenty-one minutes.

I travelled on,  and still met more the farther I proceeded. The air was literally filled with Pigeons; the light of noon-day was  obscured as by an eclipse; the dung fell in spots, not  unlike melting flakes of snow; and the continued buzz of wings had a  tendency to lull my senses to repose.” [♪♪ INTRO ♪♪] Martha died on September 1st,  1914 in Cincinnati, Ohio. She was 29.

While it’s not unusual for  celebrities to die tragically young,   Martha wasn’t your average Hollywood starlet – she was something even more rare: an endling, the last member of her species. With her death, the passenger  pigeon became extinct. Just a few hundred years earlier,   these birds are estimated to have  numbered between 3 and 5 billion – their flocks were so large that when they passed,  they could literally darken the sky for hours,   as you heard in the first-hand account  by John James Audubon in the intro.

So how did we get from the passenger pigeon making   up as much as 40% of the total bird  population of North America to now? What was it about them that  allowed them to be so abundant… until they weren’t? And are they really gone for good?

Turns out, their extinction – and potential de-extinction – comes down to a clash between  their biology and our technology. [♪♪ MUSIC ♪♪] 500 years ago, North America looked  very different than it does today. Vast forests covered much of the  eastern half of the continent,   from the Rocky Mountains to the Atlantic Ocean,  from southern Canada to northern Florida. And in those forests lived passenger pigeons.

They weren’t especially flashy birds – if you saw one perched on a  branch outside your window today,   you’d probably think, ‘yeah, that’s a pigeon.’ Or, if you happen to be a birder,   you might mistake it for a  larger-than-average mourning dove. But the chance that you would see  only one passenger pigeon in a   tree is what really set them apart  from their still-living relatives… because you’d pretty much never see just one. In the late winter or early spring, they  would collect into huge flocks to migrate   from the southern forests where they’d spent  the winter to their northern breeding grounds.

Imagine for a second hundreds of  millions of pigeons flying from   Atlanta to Philadelphia or Detroit every March. And wherever they stopped to roost for the  night or in bad weather felt the effects: they toppled trees and broke  branches under their weight,   while leaving carpets of poop behind them that choked out grasses and other plants. These stopover points were so dense with pigeons,  they would literally roost on top of each other.

Once they reached their nesting  grounds, though, they spread out a bit. And by “a bit,” I mean over 80 square kilometers,   on average, with estimates ranging from 15 to 50 nests per tree. They would stay at these nesting sites  for about a month in the late spring   or early summer, with each pair of  pigeons laying just a single egg,   and the whole colony often laying  their eggs on the same day.

This synchronized breeding strategy,  along with their enormous flocks,   was probably an anti-predator  adaptation called ‘predator satiation’ – literally, being too numerous for  the all the local predators to eat them all. Which is kind of ironic, for a couple of reasons. The first is that the preferred food source of the   passenger pigeon used that  same evolutionary strategy.

The huge forests of mixed hardwoods,  like oak, chestnut, and beech,   that the pigeons lived in do what’s called  ‘masting,’ where every couple of years,   they produce a gigantic amount  of seeds and nuts, all at once. Where and when trees mast changes from year to  year, which means the pigeons had to go find it,   and the huge size of their flocks meant  lots and lots of eyes looking for food. And they would absolutely clean house,  wherever they found enough mast – they were the ultimate seed  predators that could not be satiated.

And ‘predator satiation’ is  also ironic because, well… when we’re the predators, all bets are off. Here’s where that clash between pigeon biology and   human technology comes into  the picture, in the 1800s. Now, before then, both Native Americans  and colonists had hunted passenger pigeons,   first for food and later because they  were seen as pests that destroyed crops.

And you might’ve heard that we hunted  the passenger pigeon to extinction… and that is true, in a sense. But it wasn’t because we had some new or   especially advanced weapon  with which to hunt them. I mentioned before that the pigeon flocks  moved around unpredictably, because their   huge numbers required finding equally huge  amounts of mast and other food resources.

They could fly hundreds of  miles per day in search of food. And this presented a challenge for hunters  because it made the birds a moving target. And in the days before phones, how was a  hunter supposed to know where they were?

And, if the birds happened to be roosting   or nesting in a particular area,  why pay someone else to hunt them? They were easy enough to net  or shoot for food on your own. It turns out that the two pieces  of technology that spelled doom   for the passenger pigeon were  the answers to those questions: Not some new gun, but the telegraph and the railroad.

The telegraph allowed the locations of nesting colony to spread much faster than simple word of mouth. At the peak of hunting, there were something like   1000 professional pigeoners dedicated  to getting these birds to market. Additionally, the expansion of the  railroad network to cover most of   the US east of the Mississippi  meant that by the early 1860s the   pigeoners could quickly get their product  to big cities, like Chicago and New York.

It also made shipping huge  numbers of pigeons possible – one account of a nesting harvest in 1860 saw over   100,000 pounds of meat sent  by train to distant markets. And nesting colonies were the primary  targets of the professional pigeoners,   because the young birds were easy prey. Ultimately, these nesting hunts  meant that entire generations of   passenger pigeons were lost before  they could replace themselves… Before they could even leave their nests.

And if the parents escaped  the slaughter, they wouldn’t   lay another egg that season,  causing the population to plummet. What was once a successful anti-predator strategy   couldn’t hold up in the face of  humans hunting for the market. In 1887, the last reported colonial nesting of  the passenger pigeon happened in Wisconsin.

It was unsuccessful, probably due  to hunters disturbing the birds – they abandoned the site after about two weeks. Just a few years later, in 1902,   the last confirmed shooting of a passenger  pigeon in the wild took place in Indiana. By March 1909, the entire population consisted  of Martha and two males in the Cincinnati Zoo.

And from July 1910 until her death  in 1914, it was just Martha, alone. The endling. Her final resting place is the Smithsonian  National Museum of Natural History,   where she’s been part of several  exhibits over the last century – eternally perched on a branch,   as though pausing for a moment to  watch countless humans stream past.

But what would it take to see her species fly again? The extinction of the passenger pigeon happened  before the conservation movement got started   and the few legal protections that attempted  to save the birds were too little, too late. But are we still too late?

Much like the telegraph and  the railroad changed the fate   of the passenger pigeon the first time  around, can our technology change it again? This is the promise of de-extinction – that we can resurrect species that  have no living representatives. Or, at least, that’s how the term often  gets used in things like press releases,   conjuring images of woolly mammoths  once again stomping across the tundra.

The reality of de-extinction is more nuanced – and more complicated. If you dig past the Jurassic  Park-esque press coverage,   groups like the International Union  for the Conservation of Nature – the folks who maintain the Red  List of endangered species – give a different definition. Their guidelines focus on de-extinction as a  process for creating substitutes for extinct   species that resemble them in some key way for the  purposes of restoring lost ecological functions.

It’s less about the extinct species itself and  more about its former role in the ecosystem. And there are essentially three ways  to do this kind of de-extinction. First, there’s back-breeding.

This is just a specific kind of artificial  selection, where instead of mating pairs of   animals in hopes of producing new traits, you  pick your pairs with an eye toward old traits. Of course, this requires having a living species   that has some of the traits of the  species you’re trying to resurrect. The longest-running example of this might  be the attempt to back-breed the ancestor   of domestic cattle, the aurochs,  which some people hope to release   into the grasslands of Europe to help  maintain their openness and biodiversity.

The second way to attempt  de-extinction is through cloning. To clone an animal, you take the  nucleus of an adult somatic cell – so, any cell that’s not an egg or sperm cell – and stick it into an egg  that’s had its nucleus removed. The egg basically resets the somatic cell   so it develops like a fertilized  embryo inside a surrogate mother.

Unlike back-breeding, cloning produces  an animal that’s genetically identical   to the donor of the somatic cell, but  you need intact living cells to do it… and we don’t have those for most extinct species. We did do this kind of de-extinction  successfully once though…sort of. In 2003, scientists cloned an extinct subspecies  of Spanish ibex, but the calf died a few minutes   after birth, making this the only time we  know of that a species has gone extinct twice.

And the final option for  de-extinction is genetic engineering. This requires sequencing and assembling the  genome of an extinct species from fragments   of preserved DNA, figuring out which genes  go with which traits, and editing those genes   in a living cell from a close relative to  match the sequence of the extinct species. Then, you circle back to option 2: cloning, using the edited  somatic cell as your donor.

But, the thing is, there can be millions  of genes that differ between an extinct   species and their closest living relative,  not to mention some species don’t   have living relatives close enough to use  as a guide for assembling their genome. And not every extinct species left enough intact  DNA behind to even sequence their whole genome. Cloning also doesn’t work  for animals that lay eggs – it only works in placental mammals.

But that hasn’t stopped the organization working  on the de-extinction of the passenger pigeon. It’s called Revive & Restore and they aim  to have hatched their first pigeons by 2032. They plan to use DNA from museum specimens  of the passenger pigeon to reconstruct the   genomes of multiple individuals, then edit some  of the genes of their closest living relative – the band-tailed pigeon – to match.

Without getting too far into the biotech  weeds here, they plan to put these gene-edited   cells into gonads of rock doves, which are super easy to breed. Then, when those rock doves have babies, they'll hatch out birds that are essentially part passenger pigeon, part band-tailed pigeon. which they’ll then try to raise in a colony to  bring out their passenger pigeon-like traits. There’s a lot more to it than that,  but their ultimate goal is to restore   the passenger pigeon to its former role as an  ecosystem engineer of eastern hardwood forests.

Remember earlier, when I mentioned how these  birds used to break branches,   and topple trees, and carpet the forest  floor with poop wherever they stopped? Turns out, all that disturbance was actually  really important for these ecosystems.  In their natural state, forests  essentially go through cycles. These start when a fire or a  storm or a gigantic flock of   birds create open spaces in the canopy  for light to reach the forest floor.

This allows plants that couldn’t grow in the  shade to gain a foothold, and ultimately creates   a patchwork of habitats throughout a forest in  different stages of what’s called succession – changes in the plant community over time. This patchwork maintains biodiversity in  the forest, both in terms of the plants   that can grow there and also because it provides  a variety of habitats used by different animals. So bringing back a version of the  passenger pigeon has the potential   to kickstart these cycles again,  according to Revive & Restore – a technological solution to a biological problem.

But, at its core, does this version of   de-extinction really undo what  is lost when an endling dies? When the last member of a species that  has persisted for thousands or millions   of years meets its end, what disappears  along with it that we can’t preserve? We have the bodies of passenger pigeons  safely tucked away in museum collections,   and, in those pigeons’ cells, their genome.

We have written accounts and artwork, and  even musical notation of their calls. But no one alive today has the experience  of seeing a billion birds fly overhead. The world has changed a lot since Martha’s death,   but the passenger pigeon  hasn’t changed along with it – it hasn’t had the opportunity to adapt  to meet the challenges of this century.

And maybe it’s that chance to evolve – to shape its own fate, in a sense – that’s missing. [♪♪ MUSIC ♪♪] Endlings is filmed in the Harry Plumley Studio,   and was made possible by hundreds of you  who supported this idea on Kickstarter. Thank you so much for doing that, we really  could not have done this without you. This week, we want to get a special  shoutout to Bradley.

Thank you. We’d like to thank National Geographic  Photo Ark for their help on this episode! Finding images of these critters is not easy,   so we really appreciate the ability to work  with them to show these animals to you. [♪♪ OUTRO ♪♪]