| YouTube: | https://youtube.com/watch?v=2dGB9Fo4hnU |
| Previous: | The Weirdest Adoptions in the Animal Kingdom |
| Next: | This Island Might Help Us Understand The Origins of Life |
Categories
Statistics
| View count: | 123,046 |
| Likes: | 5,801 |
| Comments: | 286 |
| Duration: | 08:24 |
| Uploaded: | 2025-12-01 |
| Last sync: | 2026-08-10 04:30 |
Citation
| Citation formatting is not guaranteed to be accurate. | |
| MLA Full: | "Many Crystals Take Millions of Years to Form, Not These." YouTube, uploaded by SciShow, 1 December 2025, www.youtube.com/watch?v=2dGB9Fo4hnU. |
| MLA Inline: | (SciShow, 2025) |
| APA Full: | SciShow. (2025, December 1). Many Crystals Take Millions of Years to Form, Not These [Video]. YouTube. https://youtube.com/watch?v=2dGB9Fo4hnU |
| APA Inline: | (SciShow, 2025) |
| Chicago Full: |
SciShow, "Many Crystals Take Millions of Years to Form, Not These.", December 1, 2025, YouTube, 08:24, https://youtube.com/watch?v=2dGB9Fo4hnU. |
Subscribe to the SciShow Rocks Box to receive your own desert rose here! https://complexly.info/desertrose
This month's Rocks Box subscribers get a desert rose! Its floral appearance comes from crystalline combinations of different minerals that come together in dry places like Qatar and Oklahoma.
Hosted by: Savannah Geary (they/them)
----------
Support us for $8/month on Patreon and keep SciShow going!
https://www.patreon.com/scishow
Or support us directly: https://complexly.com/support
Join our SciShow email list to get the latest news and highlights:
https://mailchi.mp/scishow/email
----------
Huge thanks go to the following Patreon supporters for helping us keep SciShow free for everyone forever: Jp Lynch, J.V. Rosenbalm, Cye Stoner, Chris Curry, Bethany Matthews, David Johnston, Steve Gums, Kevin Knupp, Kevin Bealer, Matt Curls, Joseph Ruf, Alan Wong, Eric Jensen, Jaap Westera, Garrett Galloway, Jeremy Mattern, Lyndsay Brown, Toyas Dhake, Jason A Saslow, Blood Doctor Kelly, Alex Hackman, Piya Shedden, Chris Mackey, Chris Peters, Adam Brainard, Friso
----------
Looking for SciShow elsewhere on the internet?
SciShow Tangents Podcast: https://scishow-tangents.simplecast.com/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@scishow
Instagram: http://instagram.com/thescishow
Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/scishow
Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/scishow.bsky.social
#SciShow #science #education #learning #complexly
----------
Sources: https://docs.google.com/document/u/1/d/e/2PACX-1vRj4rYorUFZuMbkiz_N0eAcLCPp0FvKjZDYlBW6Kvs55f8clF_DAnbtJqQdCvgDZyjXqbIPj4JIyQ8R/pub
This month's Rocks Box subscribers get a desert rose! Its floral appearance comes from crystalline combinations of different minerals that come together in dry places like Qatar and Oklahoma.
Hosted by: Savannah Geary (they/them)
----------
Support us for $8/month on Patreon and keep SciShow going!
https://www.patreon.com/scishow
Or support us directly: https://complexly.com/support
Join our SciShow email list to get the latest news and highlights:
https://mailchi.mp/scishow/email
----------
Huge thanks go to the following Patreon supporters for helping us keep SciShow free for everyone forever: Jp Lynch, J.V. Rosenbalm, Cye Stoner, Chris Curry, Bethany Matthews, David Johnston, Steve Gums, Kevin Knupp, Kevin Bealer, Matt Curls, Joseph Ruf, Alan Wong, Eric Jensen, Jaap Westera, Garrett Galloway, Jeremy Mattern, Lyndsay Brown, Toyas Dhake, Jason A Saslow, Blood Doctor Kelly, Alex Hackman, Piya Shedden, Chris Mackey, Chris Peters, Adam Brainard, Friso
----------
Looking for SciShow elsewhere on the internet?
SciShow Tangents Podcast: https://scishow-tangents.simplecast.com/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@scishow
Instagram: http://instagram.com/thescishow
Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/scishow
Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/scishow.bsky.social
#SciShow #science #education #learning #complexly
----------
Sources: https://docs.google.com/document/u/1/d/e/2PACX-1vRj4rYorUFZuMbkiz_N0eAcLCPp0FvKjZDYlBW6Kvs55f8clF_DAnbtJqQdCvgDZyjXqbIPj4JIyQ8R/pub
Most of the big, stunning crystals that we find on Earth are the end result of millions of years of formation.
They grow deep in the Earth’s crust in tectonic processes, or on the Earth’s surface in sealed caves, in both cases taking eons to form and be found. But there’s one collectible crystal that sometimes forms a lot faster.
In a windswept desert along the coast of Qatar, gorgeous formations of desert rose are created in a matter of decades, right beneath our feet. [♪ INTRO] Desert rose crystals are common sights in museum gift shops. They’re named, somewhat uncreatively, for their rose-like appearance and sandy texture. What sets them apart from all of the shiny faceted specimens on the shelf is that the desert rose isn’t technically mineral at all, but a combination of minerals.
It’s made from flattened crystals of evaporite minerals, like gypsum or barite, that have grains of quartz peppered through them like chocolate chips in a muffin, only a lot less tasty. Please don’t eat the desert rose. Now, normally, minerals combined together like this would be classified as a rock, but rocks don’t have a predetermined shape.
And although the shape of that rock formation can vary, we always find this combo as bundles of these flattened crystals. So desert rose is really neither a mineral nor a rock. It’s its own unique thing, with a unique formation process.
It starts with evaporites. As their name suggests, these are minerals that form when saline waters evaporate. Common table salt, which in the mineral world is called halite, is technically an evaporite, and there are more than 100 other types of evaporites too.
One group have sulphates in their mineral structure, and are pretty stable over long periods, and it’s these that form the basis for desert roses. For instance, gypsum is calcium sulphate with a bit of water mixed in, barite is barium sulphate, and celestine is strontium sulphate. Which mineral you get depends on the specific chemistry of the water you’re starting with, and how much of that water has already evaporated.
Evaporating water forms a succession of minerals in order of solubility, with the least soluble - like calcium carbonate, precipitating out first, and the most soluble, like halite, precipitating out last. The sulphates fall somewhere in the middle of this succession, but you have to shift a fair bit of water to get at them. For instance, to get just 1cm thickness of gypsum, you’d need to evaporate 25 meters of normal seawater.
But making evaporites is only half of the desert rose story. In order to create the distinctive sandy texture, the evaporite minerals need to begin growing in the pore spaces of existing sandy sediments or sandstones. So, as the crystal grows, it swallows up the sand grains and incorporates them into its structure.
Gypsum and barite naturally form tabular crystals, which become the flattened petals of the rose, and when these all start growing from a single central point, they end up radiating outwards to form a unique and distinctive three-dimensional shape. The flattened barite crystals extend outward from their edges, and organic matter inside the sediment is thought to interfere with their growth, rounding off the corners to make the petals rounded, enhancing the rose-like appearance. Now, given that the raw ingredients of desert rose are essentially salty water and sand, we can theoretically find them wherever these two coexist for long enough for that water to evaporate.
This isn’t as easy as it sounds, though - you’re not going to find them on your average sandy beach, because water doesn’t stick around there long enough to evaporate. Instead, desert rose specimens are often found in unexpected places like the famously dry Sahara, the Chihuahuan desert of Mexico and, remarkably, Oklahoma! The residents of Oklahoma were so taken with their crystal bounty that the desert roses there, made of barite, have been named the official state rock.
And they’ve been created without any input from the salty seas at all. Instead, brines are thought to have risen up from deep inside the crust, as a byproduct of organic matter being cooked into oil. These brines penetrated the 250 million year old Garber sandstone, flowing through cracks in the Permian rock and evaporating very gradually, allowing barite to grow and desert roses to form around those cracks.
As the ancient sandstone is uplifted, it’s weathered back into sediment, but the desert roses survive, popping out like actual flowers on the surface. Because all of this happened deep underground, scientists don’t have a very good idea of exactly when the desert roses of Oklahoma formed. We know they must be younger than the 250 million-year-old sandstone that hosted them as they grew, but the other processes still point to a process lasting many millions of years.
Oil and its associated brine takes millions of years to cook, water will evaporate incredibly slowly while it’s still underground, and then it’ll take millions of years more for the sandstone to be uplifted and weathered. All of that points to an ancient state rock that, like most other rocks, is a product of eons. Oklahoma, I would shame you for making your state rock… not a rock.
But we putting this in the “Rocks Box,” so I actually don’t think we have room to talk. However, in one part of the Arabian peninsula, very similar specimens are being created under very different circumstances that have fast-tracked their formation. Like much of Arabia, the landscape of Qatar is dominated by deserts, and if you take a stroll along some of the deserts near the coast, there’s a good chance you’ll stub your toe on desert roses right there at the surface.
These coastal environments are what’s known as sabkhas: coastal salt flats whose landscape is dominated by alternating flooding and evaporation. In southwestern Qatar in particular, the Umm Said sabkha stretches for more than 30 kilometers along the coast of the Persian gulf, and it’s here that some of the most remarkable, modern desert roses are found, made of gypsum. Researchers think that the hot, dry climate boosts evaporation of water from the sabkha’s shallow water table, which then pulls salty water into the groundwater from the nearby ocean.
With constant evaporation and constant salty resupply, the levels of dissolved salts in the groundwater here can become extremely high, allowing evaporite minerals to precipitate and desert roses to form right at the water table. Now, the conditions need to be just right for this to happen. Too close to the sea, and the groundwater will be diluted by lower salinity water.
Too far, and the seawater won’t be pumped in at all. And the level of the water table is important too. It seems like the desert roses crystallize when the water table is between half a meter and one and a half meters below the surface.
If it’s deeper, then the evaporation isn’t strong enough to form gypsum. And if it’s shallower, the evaporation is so strong that a salt crust forms, and stunts the growth of roses. But across the sabkhas of Qatar, these conditions are all met, to help desert roses grow just below the surface.
Then, as the desert winds blow the surface sand away, the treasures are exposed. Unlike the roses of Oklahoma, which were formed by millions of years old brine inside hundreds of millions of years old rock, it’s thought that these Qatari desert roses take just a few decades to form. Which is basically nothing in geological terms!
Not only are they modern creations, but they’re constantly being renewed by salty water from the Arabian gulf, making this unique desert environment a crystal factory for desert roses. This month, SciShow Rocks Box subscribers will receive their own crystal flower in the mail, all the way from sunny Oklahoma. Every month, Rocks Box subscribers get a piece of our planet’s geological record, whether it’s a mineral, a fossil, or a multi-layered evaporite crystal, which is… not a rock.
If you want to learn more, head over to SciShow. Rocks and check it out. We also have a few a la carte minerals to peruse along with other merch.
Thanks for watching! [♪ OUTRO]
They grow deep in the Earth’s crust in tectonic processes, or on the Earth’s surface in sealed caves, in both cases taking eons to form and be found. But there’s one collectible crystal that sometimes forms a lot faster.
In a windswept desert along the coast of Qatar, gorgeous formations of desert rose are created in a matter of decades, right beneath our feet. [♪ INTRO] Desert rose crystals are common sights in museum gift shops. They’re named, somewhat uncreatively, for their rose-like appearance and sandy texture. What sets them apart from all of the shiny faceted specimens on the shelf is that the desert rose isn’t technically mineral at all, but a combination of minerals.
It’s made from flattened crystals of evaporite minerals, like gypsum or barite, that have grains of quartz peppered through them like chocolate chips in a muffin, only a lot less tasty. Please don’t eat the desert rose. Now, normally, minerals combined together like this would be classified as a rock, but rocks don’t have a predetermined shape.
And although the shape of that rock formation can vary, we always find this combo as bundles of these flattened crystals. So desert rose is really neither a mineral nor a rock. It’s its own unique thing, with a unique formation process.
It starts with evaporites. As their name suggests, these are minerals that form when saline waters evaporate. Common table salt, which in the mineral world is called halite, is technically an evaporite, and there are more than 100 other types of evaporites too.
One group have sulphates in their mineral structure, and are pretty stable over long periods, and it’s these that form the basis for desert roses. For instance, gypsum is calcium sulphate with a bit of water mixed in, barite is barium sulphate, and celestine is strontium sulphate. Which mineral you get depends on the specific chemistry of the water you’re starting with, and how much of that water has already evaporated.
Evaporating water forms a succession of minerals in order of solubility, with the least soluble - like calcium carbonate, precipitating out first, and the most soluble, like halite, precipitating out last. The sulphates fall somewhere in the middle of this succession, but you have to shift a fair bit of water to get at them. For instance, to get just 1cm thickness of gypsum, you’d need to evaporate 25 meters of normal seawater.
But making evaporites is only half of the desert rose story. In order to create the distinctive sandy texture, the evaporite minerals need to begin growing in the pore spaces of existing sandy sediments or sandstones. So, as the crystal grows, it swallows up the sand grains and incorporates them into its structure.
Gypsum and barite naturally form tabular crystals, which become the flattened petals of the rose, and when these all start growing from a single central point, they end up radiating outwards to form a unique and distinctive three-dimensional shape. The flattened barite crystals extend outward from their edges, and organic matter inside the sediment is thought to interfere with their growth, rounding off the corners to make the petals rounded, enhancing the rose-like appearance. Now, given that the raw ingredients of desert rose are essentially salty water and sand, we can theoretically find them wherever these two coexist for long enough for that water to evaporate.
This isn’t as easy as it sounds, though - you’re not going to find them on your average sandy beach, because water doesn’t stick around there long enough to evaporate. Instead, desert rose specimens are often found in unexpected places like the famously dry Sahara, the Chihuahuan desert of Mexico and, remarkably, Oklahoma! The residents of Oklahoma were so taken with their crystal bounty that the desert roses there, made of barite, have been named the official state rock.
And they’ve been created without any input from the salty seas at all. Instead, brines are thought to have risen up from deep inside the crust, as a byproduct of organic matter being cooked into oil. These brines penetrated the 250 million year old Garber sandstone, flowing through cracks in the Permian rock and evaporating very gradually, allowing barite to grow and desert roses to form around those cracks.
As the ancient sandstone is uplifted, it’s weathered back into sediment, but the desert roses survive, popping out like actual flowers on the surface. Because all of this happened deep underground, scientists don’t have a very good idea of exactly when the desert roses of Oklahoma formed. We know they must be younger than the 250 million-year-old sandstone that hosted them as they grew, but the other processes still point to a process lasting many millions of years.
Oil and its associated brine takes millions of years to cook, water will evaporate incredibly slowly while it’s still underground, and then it’ll take millions of years more for the sandstone to be uplifted and weathered. All of that points to an ancient state rock that, like most other rocks, is a product of eons. Oklahoma, I would shame you for making your state rock… not a rock.
But we putting this in the “Rocks Box,” so I actually don’t think we have room to talk. However, in one part of the Arabian peninsula, very similar specimens are being created under very different circumstances that have fast-tracked their formation. Like much of Arabia, the landscape of Qatar is dominated by deserts, and if you take a stroll along some of the deserts near the coast, there’s a good chance you’ll stub your toe on desert roses right there at the surface.
These coastal environments are what’s known as sabkhas: coastal salt flats whose landscape is dominated by alternating flooding and evaporation. In southwestern Qatar in particular, the Umm Said sabkha stretches for more than 30 kilometers along the coast of the Persian gulf, and it’s here that some of the most remarkable, modern desert roses are found, made of gypsum. Researchers think that the hot, dry climate boosts evaporation of water from the sabkha’s shallow water table, which then pulls salty water into the groundwater from the nearby ocean.
With constant evaporation and constant salty resupply, the levels of dissolved salts in the groundwater here can become extremely high, allowing evaporite minerals to precipitate and desert roses to form right at the water table. Now, the conditions need to be just right for this to happen. Too close to the sea, and the groundwater will be diluted by lower salinity water.
Too far, and the seawater won’t be pumped in at all. And the level of the water table is important too. It seems like the desert roses crystallize when the water table is between half a meter and one and a half meters below the surface.
If it’s deeper, then the evaporation isn’t strong enough to form gypsum. And if it’s shallower, the evaporation is so strong that a salt crust forms, and stunts the growth of roses. But across the sabkhas of Qatar, these conditions are all met, to help desert roses grow just below the surface.
Then, as the desert winds blow the surface sand away, the treasures are exposed. Unlike the roses of Oklahoma, which were formed by millions of years old brine inside hundreds of millions of years old rock, it’s thought that these Qatari desert roses take just a few decades to form. Which is basically nothing in geological terms!
Not only are they modern creations, but they’re constantly being renewed by salty water from the Arabian gulf, making this unique desert environment a crystal factory for desert roses. This month, SciShow Rocks Box subscribers will receive their own crystal flower in the mail, all the way from sunny Oklahoma. Every month, Rocks Box subscribers get a piece of our planet’s geological record, whether it’s a mineral, a fossil, or a multi-layered evaporite crystal, which is… not a rock.
If you want to learn more, head over to SciShow. Rocks and check it out. We also have a few a la carte minerals to peruse along with other merch.
Thanks for watching! [♪ OUTRO]



